Tuesday, 28 July 2015

Week 3

Glowing in the Dark



I am really interested in developing a visual solution that communicates the "current flag covers and hides NZ's real identiy" without using an image of the flag -> in order to add more depth to my design and make the rhetorical devices more engaging (i.e. multiple layers, multiple meanings, a visual riddle,....). I had an idea that really excited me:

There's an experiment for kids, where you write something on a white piece of paper using lemon juice. The message stays hidden and invisible until you apply heat using an iron or lighter. I thought it would be great to have a blank piece of A2 paper with my heading and tagline that suggests to the viewer that the current flag design only shows one side of NZ's identity. However, when the paper comes in contact with heat, a design of the "true NZ" is revealed. Issues are that I firstly, do not want to accidentally set my design on fire plus this concept might be quite unpractical in action. But I still think its cool, I would love to try it - maybe there are different mediums?

In Chemistry at High School you can use a certain type of paper that, when a basic or acidic liquid is poured on top, it changes colour - either blue for a basic solution or red for acid. But then again that paper needs to be fully wet in order to change colour plus that specific paper normally comes in the size of like 2cm by 8cm. Since our final Hand-in will be A2 format, this might bee a bit far. 


Next idea I had was to use Glow in the Dark paint. Same concept, white paper with heading and tagline, but with the natural change of light, my poster reveals the other side of the message. This also doesn't have the issue that my tutors saw with my previous ideas: It doesn't require the audience to interact with the design in order for it to work. I guess you could argue that I would have to consider who would see the poster at night time, that it will have a different audience compared to the day time and it might be limited. However, it is winter. Sun sets at 5:30. So duh

Sunday, 26 July 2015

Week 3

How people attach images to walls

 

Matt suggested to use a person pasting up a poster as an element of my actual poster (to emphasise the covering up of something). This provoked me to do some research into graffiti as an art form and techniques associated with the activity. I discovered that there are numerous ways of designing and making a graffiti piece. One technique particularly stood out to me: Paste Up Graffiti. The artist develops an image, mostly of political content or a current societal issue, at home and then pastes the image up using a type of wheat glue. This technique enables the artist to create images with more depth than most other graffiti as he is able to work on it at home without the pressure to be discovered in the streets. The image can be easily reproduced numerous times. Interesting enough, this type of graffiti usually doesn't last as long as others because the glue will resolve and general weather conditions influence how long it lasts. Often other paste up artists will also cover the previous work after a short period of time. 

Source: https://coretv1.wordpress.com/2008/12/23/paste-up-graffiti-hitting-new-frontiers/

I researched two artists that were mentioned in the article. 

A woman called SWOON:

I think her use of lines is very effective and expressive. I also enjoy the wealth of different patterns she applies to her work (especially in the third image).














 An another artist who uses the same technique, called Goldie:

He tends to use a more Collage type approach.









In response to my tutor's feedback and the above research, I created another ideation of the "covering the reality" concept (similar to my second poster idea that I presented for the interim). The idea is to have a poster that has two layers. The viewer sees a situation of someone pasting the flag over "the real NZ". However, the poster becomes interactive with the viewer peeling the Flag layer off to reveal what is being covered up.








Update: Matt said I should rather use a 2 dimensional approach and think of visual solutions that do not require the audience....hmm...downbuzz

Week 3, Session 1

Different Voices

When presenting our posters, we were required to say our titles out loud using different voices. This really helped with understanding how your poster can change "its voice" and how a different tone can so easily change the overall meaning of the message. Our tutors encouraged us to think about the type and FADP's we are using in a similar way. The different voices can be translated visually by changing the size of the type or develop variations of a subjects positioning (like when Alfred hoped on the table and suddenly we all had to look up to him). 

Furthermore, we also had a lecture on the use of visual language. We were shown a variety of images and were asked to analyse the ihi/wehi. 

Week 3, Session 1

Feedback from Interim Presentation


Due to poor time-management, I only managed to physically do 2 posters for the presentation despite the fact we were asked to do 4...

Below is the first poster I had:


Three words to describe the design:

Covered
Pull
Reality

Basically, the underlying concept is that the current flag is a misrepresentation of New Zealand because in reality, there is so much more to our nation that its colonial heritage. The present flag design covers up all the other elements that make New Zealand special and contribute to its national identity. However, in order to reveal what's (physically) covered, the viewer has to pull the poster apart. Therefore, on a more subconscious level, the poster asks the viewer to not only change their viewpoint of the flag design but also asks them to join in the discussion and actually help make a change. 



Poster numero due:



Three words to describe the design:

Shadow
Attached
History


This design solution addresses an issue raised by people against the flag. They argue that changing the flag will disconnect New Zealander's from their past and is disrespectful towards soldiers that died under the current flag design. In my opinion, that argument is absolutely ridiculous. However, I came across it numerous times, so obviously it is a crucial point to a vast number of people. My personal viewpoint is that changing the flag will not disconnect Kiwi's from their past and it is also not offensive towards their ancestors. A nation's and therefore an individual's history will always be attached and part of them in one way or another. In some situations more than in others. This is symbolised in my poster through the shadow that displays the Union Jack (i.e. colonial past). However, it is no good to always look back and it is time for New Zealand to take a step forward in order to sustain a strong national identity (symbolised by people walking and physically standing up from the two-dimensional poster). The poster would also be interactive because the viewer is required to remove the front layer of people (currently black silhouettes) in order for them to be able to stand up. 



Overall Feedback:

My classmates really liked my idea of an interactive poster. However said that at this point (especially the first poster) doesn't really make it clear what you are supposed to do with it. My tutors also found the designs appealing but mentioned that making the posters 3D to a degree may not respond to the brief correctly. Matt suggested to look into peeling a layer off or use those roller thingys people tend to use when pasting up posters onto walls. BUT I really like the interactive posters that change shape, are pulled or stand up. I understand that it might be a bit risky but I still want to try it out and see if I can convince my tutors of the opposite.

Friday, 24 July 2015

Week 2

Reconsidering my current ideas

 

I am sort of stuck with my ideas, don't really know how to push them further and also don't really like them. When trying to overcome my mental block, I remembered a poster that I saw on Cuba Street last year. I can't recall exactly what the advertisement was for, I think it was something to do with a mobile provider who promised that if you signed up for a plan with them, you will get a free premium membership on Spotify - something along those lines. Anyway, when you physically touched certain parts off the poster, it would make a noise - like a beat or someone singing, etc. You could touch multiple parts at the same time to create a song. Similar to the sound table in TePapa, I suppose. This got me thinking. Developing a poster that creates sounds upon touching it might be a bit too intensive for a 6 week project. However, I really like the idea that it was interactive. After all, I still remember seeing it and what noises it made. Hence, successful advertising that successfully engaged the viewer in a memorable way. I would love to develop a poster that requires the viewer in order to bring across its message! A poster that engages the audience not only on a 2 dimensional level (I am aware that the overall final poster design is supposed to be 2D)


Stuff I considered/ What is familiar about posters and how do you make it unfamiliar?


I started off reconsidering what a flat sheet of paper, i.e. poster, means, what it is capable off and what its limits are. It can be folded, ripped, crumbled up, "decrumbled", teared apart, layered on top of each other, stretched, hung up, cut, pulled apart, glued together, knotted, dipped in water, sewn through, weaved, etc. I tried these ideas. They all had different effects on the material in terms of texture, shape and the degree of transparency. Below are some images of my tests:















Something else I thought about was the positioning of a poster. Usually posters are hung up on eye level, billboards, big buildings, etc. But what about if a poser was glued to the floor or ground? Or what if it was attached to the ceiling? Or in the corner of a room? How would that affect the design...since it is in an awkward spot where you might not necessarily look, you would have to make it " extra eye-catchy". Or do you not actually have to, exactly because it is in a strange spot and just by its positioning attracts attention? How does it affect the audience, i.e. they would look down on it or uncomfortably let their head fall back in order to be able to look at it. At this point, I am not entirely sure how to incorporate this thinking into my design, however it has helped me a lot in terms of pushing my ideas.





Tuesday, 21 July 2015

Week 2, Session 2

 Making the familiar unfamiliar



Today, we had a lecture on the 3 forms of rhetoric. The ones we focused on were: Juxtaposition, Substitution/Addition and Pastiche. We also looked at the idea of "making the familiar unfamiliar". I thought that was a very interesting stance that encourages out of the box thinking. It basically helps to reinvent an existing object or look at a certain point of view in a different way. An object or image is used in a different environment or way to communicate a new idea or different view point to what it normally represents. I found a corresponding reading on Stream. I chose a couple of images from this source that I found to be particularly thought-provoking. I also researched and found a few more images that use the same technique.


















Monday, 20 July 2015

Week 2

Generating Ideas

Rapid Ideation/ Homework



Within class, we did a rapid ideation excercise. Each of us was given a word or phrase and we had to come up with multiple design solutions that incorporated both our issue and the word we were given. I found that very helpful as it encouraged me to not think about what my drawing looked like but rather get out some ideas. 

One of the words I got was anchor. I researched into that object's symbolic significance and used it as part of the sketches I did to develop my concept (Refer to my Physical Workbook. "HW 20/07/15 - Ideation")

Another issue I addressed when doing my sketch was that New Zealand is not only identified by its Pakeha and British colonial culture but also Maori. Both equally contribute to the country's national identity. I was playing around with using Type to emphasize that relationship: both are very different, yet work along each other are intertwined and dependent on each other. 

Another concept I came up with was using a collection of symbols that represent New Zealand's culture and proposing a rhetorical question by putting it on par with the New Zealand flag. However, I don't think this concept is very successful and I will probably not develop it any further. It is too one dimensional and this style of illustration is not suitable for this assignment.


 




Friday, 17 July 2015

Week 1

Chosen Topic: Changing the National Flag


Summarising my research findings


Using a variety of different sources, I have thoroughly considered both sides of the argument that discusses whether changing the flag is an appropriate and needed step or just a waste of time, money and resources. I have come to the conclusion that I support the remaking of the current design. 

To me, a flag is a symbol that is distinct to a certain country, tells its story and most importantly acknowledges its identity. The Maori culture, an incredibly fascinating and unique aspect that I really enjoy about New Zealand, is fundamental to Aotearoa's identity. It is not only present in everyday life, but also essential to New Zealand's social, political and cultural structures. The Maori aspect of New Zealand's national identity is, quite frankly, not depicted or acknowledged in the current design of the flag. Currently, it is all about, and only about, British imperialism. The Treaty of Waitangi recognises the right of two societies to co-exist and share this land. Despite there being a lot of social and cultural obstacles to be overcome between Maori and Pakeha, a national flag that acknowledges both groups and their background would be an important symbolic step towards a strong national identity and community - an emblem that everyone can identify with and is proud of. 






Monday, 13 July 2015

Week 1, session 2

Class Debate 



Within groups we were given a particular topic. We were asked to research the issue and support  a standpoint which were also given. My group argued for public schools. The most important and relevant points to me are as follows:

  • not as costly as private schools which range from $4,000 to $20,000 p.a. depending on the school and region (school fees, school uniform, activities like camping, etc.)
  • Money saved can be used to fund after school one-on-one tutoring if needed or extra curriculum activities such as music lessons, dance lessons, language tuition, etc. 
  • In some cases, both parents might be required to work full-time in order to be bale to afford private education for their kids. If the children attend a public school, one parent may have the option to stay at home and contribute to the child's education different to a teacher (help with homework, etc). After all, success is not only dependant on secondary education but also on supportive, engaged and encouraging parents.
  • Stats show that private schools are attended by a vast variety of kids from different backgrounds whereas private schools tend to be mostly New Zealanders of a wealthy or middle-class "white" background. Furthermore, public schools are required to accept children with disabilities. Therefore, kids get exposed to a bigger variety of people and learn appropriate interaction with other children from all walks of life. 
  • Kids have to deal with high expectations and stress levels to perform at a high standard as private schools are so expensive. This raises the question whether that facilitates or hinders successful studying.


However, the group arguing pro private schools also raised interesting and thought-provoking points:

  • Private schools have more financial funding and are therefore able to enrich the students' life and education by providing better computers, teachers, sport grounds and other facilities around school.
  • Smaller class sizes ensure more opportunities of one-on-one teaching within the class environment. it strengthens the community and relationship between students and students as well as students and teachers. Smaller class sizes also make the kids more confident to speak in front of a group and contribute to the class contents. 
  • A more appropriate amount of pressure than in public schools, encourage higher academic and sporting results. 

The other debate topic was the change of the New Zealand flag. Here is a selection of ideas of what the "contra change" group had to say:

  • Most importantly, an incredible amount of $26 million dollars is spent on this project. This money should be much rather be put towards fighting poverty or provide lunches for school children. 
  • Changing the flag would undermine New Zealands historical background.
  • Soldiers died carrying and being buried with the flag during the war, changing it would only be insulting and dishonouring their memory. 
  • Removing the Union Jack would symbolise cutting the ties with England and the Common Weatlh. Changing the flag is the easy way out to making any actual decision. 
  • It is just a symbol that, on an average day, no-one cares about so why go through the effort to change it? Most people of NZ do not actually care.

I definitely understand the issues raised arguing against a change. However, I found the speech of the "Pro-Change" group very compelling:

  • The flag is not an accurate representation of New Zealand. There are no Maori symbols or any sort of reference to New Zealand's unique indigenous population. 
  • The Union Jack doesn't necessarily represent Aotearoa's history, it is only a symbol of cultural dominance over the country. A similar situation occurred with Canada who removed the Union Jack from their flag in the 60s.  
  • Compared to money spent yearly on other things, $26 million is - in comparison - not a very big sum of money. Financial support already goes towards kid's school lunches,etc.
  • Don't underestimate the power of art and design. Renewing a symbol means a new direction and a new era. And after all, there is no reason why we can't raise the old flag on Anzac to honour our ancestors. 
  • In response to people arguing that it is a waste of money and the money is more necessary in other places: If the majority of citizens really cared that much about poverty, then National wouldn't have won the elections.

In conclusion, the class debate was an awesome way to inform yourself and research a topic. The speeches were very impressive and definitely thought-provoking!





Week 1

Three additional examples of Ihi and Wehi


"Obsession and Fantasy" (1963) by Robert Brownjohn





Ihi: Visual pun (nipples resemble the letter "O"). Using colour symbolism (bright red "and fantasy" balances against the powerful and memorable photographic image). Asymmetry. Subversion (Combination of handwritten word transforms connotation of the photographic image). Bold and Capital letters ad high contrast make the message powerful and clear. 

Wehi: "Sex Sells" (Naked upper female body instantly captures the audiences attention). "And fantasy" in red type enforces the connotation of sex and pleasure. Visual pun is humorous and incredibly well integrated which makes the image very effective and memorable. 



"Apartheid/ Racisme" (1986) by French collective Grapus






Ihi: Representation of a skull that's missing the lower part, in the shape of a map of Africa. Difference in size and using the map to form holes for the eyes and nostrils to create the skull (Subversion). Handwritten typography repeats violent and jagged look of the map/skull. 

Wehi: Symbolism and choice of illustration clearly communicate a sense of death and looks intimidating and macabre. The map in combination with the connotation of a skull illustrates the partition between black and white, i.e. racial discrimination. 

An interesting side note I found while researching the background of this image: The significance of skulls within art and design has varied over time. It can be found as religious emblems, anti-war symbols, danger, expression of spiritual angst, but also as a symbol of charm (modern art!). In this context, the term "Vanitas" can be found very frequently. In the arts, it refers to symbolic works of art (especially Dutch artists) that often show skulls reflecting on death and decay. 




Eye - Bee - M (1981) by Paul Rand






Ihi: Symbolic illustration of an eye, a bee and the letter M. The stripes, most obvious in the M, give the first instant clue that this might be related to the famous logo of IBM, the American technology and consulting corporation. Very graphic and clean look. However, the illustrations are still very playful. High contrast in colour. Clear and clean grid/ structure. Balanced, yet asymmetric. 

Wehi: Intriguing to the audience, because it is like a visual riddle. The stripes give off a first clue, yet you need to engage with the work to fully understand it. Only when one pronounces the denotations of the Eye (I), Bee (B), M (M) out loud, you will solve it. 
















Week 1, session 1

Introduction to brief and the Maori concept of Ihi and Wehi



Today's lecture had a particular focus on Ihi and Wehi and how they are used within Designs. Ihi and Wehi are Maori terms that are associated with emotional and psychological behaviour. "Ihi can be described as an individual’s essential force, charisma, power or charm – which emanates throughout the creative processess. Wehi, on the other hand, highlights the internalised feelings that occur in response to ihi." 

Within the context of Art and Design, these two ideas can be understood as the Denotation and the Connotation. Ihi is what can be physically seen in a piece of art or design, whereas wehi is the psychological or emotional response of the viewer (i.e. An image of a skull. Denotation/Ihi is that it is an image of a skull. Connotaion/Wehi is that it symbolises death, danger, poison, etc.). Wehi can vary depending on the context and the personal background of the audience. Symbols can be combined to combined in order to change the message (Subversion - "The addition/subtraction or manipulation of an existing element to introduce a new idea). 

Within class we were provided a selection of images which we used to identify and discuss Ihi and Wehi. As part of our homework, we were asked to find a further 3 examples and do the same.