Monday, 13 July 2015

Week 1, session 2

Class Debate 



Within groups we were given a particular topic. We were asked to research the issue and support  a standpoint which were also given. My group argued for public schools. The most important and relevant points to me are as follows:

  • not as costly as private schools which range from $4,000 to $20,000 p.a. depending on the school and region (school fees, school uniform, activities like camping, etc.)
  • Money saved can be used to fund after school one-on-one tutoring if needed or extra curriculum activities such as music lessons, dance lessons, language tuition, etc. 
  • In some cases, both parents might be required to work full-time in order to be bale to afford private education for their kids. If the children attend a public school, one parent may have the option to stay at home and contribute to the child's education different to a teacher (help with homework, etc). After all, success is not only dependant on secondary education but also on supportive, engaged and encouraging parents.
  • Stats show that private schools are attended by a vast variety of kids from different backgrounds whereas private schools tend to be mostly New Zealanders of a wealthy or middle-class "white" background. Furthermore, public schools are required to accept children with disabilities. Therefore, kids get exposed to a bigger variety of people and learn appropriate interaction with other children from all walks of life. 
  • Kids have to deal with high expectations and stress levels to perform at a high standard as private schools are so expensive. This raises the question whether that facilitates or hinders successful studying.


However, the group arguing pro private schools also raised interesting and thought-provoking points:

  • Private schools have more financial funding and are therefore able to enrich the students' life and education by providing better computers, teachers, sport grounds and other facilities around school.
  • Smaller class sizes ensure more opportunities of one-on-one teaching within the class environment. it strengthens the community and relationship between students and students as well as students and teachers. Smaller class sizes also make the kids more confident to speak in front of a group and contribute to the class contents. 
  • A more appropriate amount of pressure than in public schools, encourage higher academic and sporting results. 

The other debate topic was the change of the New Zealand flag. Here is a selection of ideas of what the "contra change" group had to say:

  • Most importantly, an incredible amount of $26 million dollars is spent on this project. This money should be much rather be put towards fighting poverty or provide lunches for school children. 
  • Changing the flag would undermine New Zealands historical background.
  • Soldiers died carrying and being buried with the flag during the war, changing it would only be insulting and dishonouring their memory. 
  • Removing the Union Jack would symbolise cutting the ties with England and the Common Weatlh. Changing the flag is the easy way out to making any actual decision. 
  • It is just a symbol that, on an average day, no-one cares about so why go through the effort to change it? Most people of NZ do not actually care.

I definitely understand the issues raised arguing against a change. However, I found the speech of the "Pro-Change" group very compelling:

  • The flag is not an accurate representation of New Zealand. There are no Maori symbols or any sort of reference to New Zealand's unique indigenous population. 
  • The Union Jack doesn't necessarily represent Aotearoa's history, it is only a symbol of cultural dominance over the country. A similar situation occurred with Canada who removed the Union Jack from their flag in the 60s.  
  • Compared to money spent yearly on other things, $26 million is - in comparison - not a very big sum of money. Financial support already goes towards kid's school lunches,etc.
  • Don't underestimate the power of art and design. Renewing a symbol means a new direction and a new era. And after all, there is no reason why we can't raise the old flag on Anzac to honour our ancestors. 
  • In response to people arguing that it is a waste of money and the money is more necessary in other places: If the majority of citizens really cared that much about poverty, then National wouldn't have won the elections.

In conclusion, the class debate was an awesome way to inform yourself and research a topic. The speeches were very impressive and definitely thought-provoking!





No comments:

Post a Comment